Tick anything you already have, in any order. Quests unlock once this is done.
Responsive means it comes back with a tug, which is what you need for the first month. Unresponsive ones look impressive and cannot do a single beginner trick.
2 things left above. Quests are real things you go and do, so they only make sense once you have what you need.
First one waiting: Get a responsive beginner yo-yo