Back

Fishkeeping vs Fly fishing

84% in common

Fishkeeping and fly fishing have 84% in common. Here is how they differ on money, time and feel, so you can pick the one that fits your week.

The practical side

  • To startFishkeeping: About $200Fly fishing: About $250
  • Each monthFishkeeping: About $20Fly fishing: About $30
  • Time a weekFishkeeping: 2 hoursFly fishing: 4 hours
  • A sessionFishkeeping: About 20 minFly fishing: About 180 min
  • WhereFishkeeping: At homeFly fishing: Out and about
  • Who withBothOn your own
  • You end up withBothA skill you got better at

How they feel

Where each one sits, from one end to the other. The ones they differ on most come first.

  • OutdoorsIndoorsOutdoors
  • Physical effortStillIntense
  • Creative freedomFollow the rulesOpen-ended
  • CollectingNoneThe point
  • ExploringSame placeAlways somewhere new
  • CompanySoloGroup
  • ThrillSafeAdrenaline
  • Hands-onHands-offHands-on
Compare all 22
  • BrainworkAutopilotIntense focus
  • PrecisionLooseMeticulous
  • Useful resultsPure joyVery useful
  • ScreensAnalogOn a screen
  • Living thingsObjectsPlants & animals
  • Something to showExperience onlyA finished thing
  • DepthShallowBottomless
  • Quick winsMonths to funFun on day one
  • CompetitionNoneThe point
  • CalmFired upSoothing
  • StudyJust do itLearning is the hobby
  • AudiencePrivateOn stage
  • RhythmAlways differentSoothing repetition
  • VarietyOld favouritesSomething new every time

Choose fishkeeping if

  • It lives indoors, whatever the weather
  • It asks almost nothing of your body
  • It's wide open for your own ideas
  • It builds a collection you'll love curating

About $200 to start, then about $20 a month.

Starter kit: Aquarium Starter Kit, Algae Scraper. See the kit

About fishkeeping

Choose fly fishing if

  • It gets you outside
  • It gets your body properly working
  • There's a clear way to do it right
  • You don't need to accumulate anything

About $250 to start, then about $30 a month.

Starter kit: Fly rod and reel combo, Fly assortment. See the kit

About fly fishing

Compare something else

Any two of the 396. You get the time each takes, what it costs to start, who you need and what you end up with.