Best Locking Carabiners (2026): The Rating On the Spine Assumes One Direction
The kilonewton figure stamped on a carabiner is measured one way: along the spine, with the gate shut.
Our pickBest for belay and rappel
BD RockLock screwgate
Black Diamond's largest locking carabiner, and the size is the point: a wide pear shape gives a belay device or a Munter hitch room to sit properly…
- ShapeLarge pear
- LockScrewgate
- NoseKeylock
Load it across its minor axis, or with the gate held open by a sling or a rock, and the real strength falls to a fraction of that number. Almost every carabiner failure is a loading problem rather than a quality problem.
The 30-second verdict
- The kN rating is spine-to-spine with the gate closed. Nothing else.
- Cross-loading across the minor axis can cut strength by two thirds or more.
- Screwgate is cheap and you must remember to lock it. Auto-locking locks itself.
- Keylock noses do not snag. Hooked noses catch on slings and bolt hangers.
- Retire anything dropped from height, deeply grooved, or with a sticking gate.
At a glance
What the numbers actually mean
Every certified carabiner carries three figures, usually as small pictograms on the spine.
- Major axis, an arrow along the length. This is the big number, typically 20 to 30 kN, measured spine-to-spine with the gate closed. The Petzl Am D here is rated 27 kN.
- Minor axis, an arrow across the width. Usually 7 to 10 kN. This is cross-loading.
- Gate open, typically 6 to 9 kN.
The gap between those is the whole safety story. A carabiner rated 27 kN along the spine may hold only 8 kN across it, and about the same with the gate held open. That is not a defect; it is how the shape works. Load passes along the spine because the spine is the solid side.
So the failure modes are positional, not material.
Cross-loading happens when a carabiner rotates so the load runs across it rather than along it — very commonly where a belay device or a sling twists in the basket. Many belay carabiners carry a captive bar or a rubber keeper specifically to stop this rotation.
Gate-open loading happens when a gate is pressed against rock, or a stiff sling holds it ajar, or vibration flutters it. A carabiner with its gate open is a hook.
Nose-hooking is when the nose catches on a bolt hanger or a sling and takes the load on the tip. This is what the keylock nose exists to prevent: a smooth notchless nose that cannot hook, instead of the traditional hooked nose with a pin.
Locking mechanism and shape
Screwgate is a sleeve you turn by hand. It is simple, cheap, lightweight, has nothing to seize up, and it is only locked if you remember to lock it. For anchors and rigging where you check everything deliberately, it is excellent. For a belay carabiner you handle constantly under stress, the fact that it can be left unlocked is the argument against it.
Auto-locking mechanisms lock themselves when released. Petzl's names are worth knowing because they come up constantly: Twist-Lock (twist only), Triact-Lock (lift then twist), Ball-Lock (push a button then twist). More actions means harder to open by accident, and harder to open with cold or gloved hands.
Then shape, which decides what it is for.
- Pear or HMS, wide at the top. The width accommodates a Munter hitch and lets a belay device sit properly. The BD RockLock here is the large version of this and is a belay and rappel carabiner.
- Asymmetric D, the most common shape. It pushes the load toward the spine, which is why it gives the best strength for the weight. The Petzl Am D is this, at 70 to 75 grams for 27 kN.
- Oval, symmetrical. It is weaker than a D for the same weight, and you choose it anyway because the uniform shape stops gear shifting inside it. That makes it the shape for pulleys, aid climbing and racking, where predictable position matters more than strength.
For canyoneering specifically, add water and grit to all of this. Sand works into screw threads and auto-locking mechanisms alike, so anything that goes in a canyon gets rinsed in fresh water, and a gate that grinds is telling you something.
The 3 picks
In the order of the table above. Our pick is outlined.
Our pick · Best for belay and rappel

BD RockLock screwgate
Listed as BLACK DIAMOND RockLock Screwgate Locking Belay/Rappelling
- Shape
- Large pear
- Lock
- Screwgate
- Nose
- Keylock
What's good
- Wide pear shape suits belay devices and Munter hitches
- Keylock nose cannot snag on slings or hangers
- Works one-handed with gloves
- Cheapest of the three
What's not
- Screwgate must be locked manually every time
- Large and heavy for racking
- No captive bar to prevent cross-loading
- Threads pick up canyon grit
Best for devices and lanyards

Petzl Am D screw-lock
Listed as PETZL, AM'D Carabiner, Black, Screw-Lock
- Shape
- Asymmetric D
- Strength
- 27 kN major axis
- Weight
- 70-75 g
What's good
- 27 kN at 70-75 g is excellent strength to weight
- D shape guides devices into correct orientation
- Keylock nose and smooth interior resist snagging
- Offered in screw, twist, triact and ball locks
What's not
- Narrower basket than a pear for Munter hitches
- Multiple lock versions make ordering confusing
- Black finish is harder to inspect for wear
- Dearer than the RockLock
Best for pulleys and racking

BD Oval keylock
Listed as Black Diamond Oval Keylock Carabiner, Black
- Shape
- Symmetrical oval
- Nose
- Keylock
- Use
- Pulleys, aid, racking
What's good
- Uniform shape stops clipped gear shifting
- Right choice for pulleys and aid climbing
- Large carrying capacity for racking
- Keylock nose, so snag-free
What's not
- Weaker per gram than an asymmetric D
- Wrong first carabiner for most people
- Dearest here by a distance
- Narrow basket for belay devices
Inspection and retirement
Check the gate every time.
It should snap shut cleanly under its own spring, and the lock should run freely. A gate that is slow, gritty or does not close fully is a carabiner to retire, and in canyoneering that is usually sand in the hinge.
Rinse in fresh water after every canyon.
Then work the gate while it dries. Salt and grit wear both the hinge and the locking threads.
Look for grooving.
Ropes wear a channel into aluminium over time, especially on rappel carabiners. A groove you can catch a fingernail in has removed material from the loaded side, and that one is done.
Retire after a significant drop.
A carabiner dropped from height onto rock can carry invisible microfractures. The fact that it looks fine is not evidence. They are cheap and you are not.
Do not lubricate with anything oily
that will transfer to a rope. A dry lubricant or graphite on the hinge only, if anything.
Mind the age of slings and ropes too.
Metal has no fixed shelf life but the textiles it connects to do, and nylon degrades with UV and age whether or not it has been used.
Mark your gear.
Shared canyon kit gets mixed up, and knowing the history of a specific carabiner is part of knowing whether to trust it.
Before you buy
0 of 5
Carabiner questions
What do the kN numbers on a carabiner mean?
Three ratings: major axis, measured spine-to-spine with the gate closed and usually 20 to 30 kN; minor axis, across the width, usually 7 to 10 kN; and gate open, typically 6 to 9 kN. The big number only applies in one direction, which is why how you load a carabiner matters more than which one you bought.
What is cross-loading and why is it dangerous?
It is when a carabiner rotates so the load runs across its width rather than along the spine, which can cut its strength by two thirds or more. It happens most often where a belay device or sling twists in the basket. Many belay carabiners have a captive bar or rubber keeper specifically to stop that rotation.
Screwgate or auto-locking?
Screwgates are cheaper, lighter and have nothing to seize, and they are only locked if you remember. That suits anchors and rigging you check deliberately. Auto-locking mechanisms lock themselves on release, which suits a belay carabiner handled constantly under stress. More actions to open means safer but harder with cold or gloved hands.
When should I retire a carabiner?
After any significant drop onto rock, since microfractures are invisible. Also if the gate is slow, gritty or does not close fully under its own spring, or if a rope has worn a groove you can catch a fingernail in. Metal has no fixed shelf life, but a carabiner you are unsure about is already retired.
Bottom line
The Black Diamond RockLock is the one to start with: a wide pear that gives a belay device room to sit properly, a keylock nose that will not snag, and a price that lets you buy several. Choose the Petzl Am D where strength to weight matters and you want a D to orient your devices. The oval is a specialist shape for pulleys and racking. Get trained before you trust any of it.
How we pick
HobbyStack Editorial
- One pick, then a cheaper and a dearer one. Most people want the thing that is right for most people. The other two are there for a tighter budget and for someone who already knows they will grow into more.
- We research canyoning gear; we do not lab-test it. Picks come from what the people who do this every week actually use, what breaks, and what gets returned, not from a scoring sheet.
- Prices come live from Amazon with the time we checked them. We never print a price we cannot date, and the price on Amazon when you buy is the one that applies.
- Nobody pays to be here. We earn a small commission if you buy through these links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. It never changes what we pick.


